Better Than Sex Mascara Review and Dupes

Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara Review
*Essie Button is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Mascara is a staple makeup item that you find in every woman’s makeup pouch. If you don’t want a heavy makeup look, then a little lip balm, blush and a few coats of mascara will do the job. In fact, mascara is what you need to put together your no-makeup makeup look. If you apply it every day, you’ll need the most durable, voluminous and lash-boosting mascara there is.

One of the best mascaras on the market is the Too Faced Better than Sex Mascara. It’s one of the most sold mascaras in the US makeup market that adds definition, volume, and thickness to your eyelashes! Even though this mascara guarantees great results, it is expensive. Our favorite dupe is L’Oréal Paris’ Lash Paradise. Read on to find out if this is the best dupe for you.

Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara Review

Too Faced Better than Sex Mascara

This formula thickens, lengthens, and curls after just one coat.

Check Current Price
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

If you’re looking for the best mascara out there, then you need to turn towards Better than Sex Mascara by Too Faced. This mascara gives a gorgeous, natural-looking finish to your eyelashes, making the base of your lashes appear thicker and darker. The Too Faced BTS mascara serves as an amazing tool for curling lashes. Its packaging is not too bad either; it comes in a pink tube with an hourglass application.

Where to buy: Amazon, ULTA

Too Faced Better than Sex Mascara Dupes

The Too Faced Better than Sex Mascara is truly the best product for your eyelashes, but it can be heavy on the wallet. Also, since mascara is worn quite often, repeat purchases are very common. So, for those who can’t or don’t want to put a dent in their bank balance, here are some of the best drugstore dupes of the Too Faced BTS mascara.

L’Oréal Paris’ Lash Paradise

Our Pick

L'Oréal Paris' Lash Paradise

This volumizing and lengthening mascara delivers a full lash fringe that’s feathery soft.

Check Current Price
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

The L’Oreal Paris Lash Paradise mascara is an amazing dupe. If you’re looking for something like the BTS mascara, then this should be your go-to option. Not only do they both come in a similar pink tube, but they also guarantee similar results. The Lash Paradise Mascara delivers intense volume to your lashes and has phenomenal black pigmentation.

It delivers on giving a full lash fringe that is feathery soft rather than flaky, smudgy or clumpy. The wavy bristle brush holds lots of mascara to deliver a dramatic and volumizing look to your eyelashes. While the first application gives your eyelashes a nice length, the second coat enhances the volume of your lashes further. You will experience minimal flaking even after an entire day of wearing this mascara!

Pros:

  • Easy and smooth application
  • Really highlights your eyelashes
  • Stays put throughout the day, even through sweat
  • Can be removed using warm water or baby wipes
  • Doesn’t cause any eye irritation
  • Doesn’t crumble or flake

Cons:

  • The applicator doesn’t taper off, which makes it difficult to cover the roots of your lashes
  • The applicator also poses the risk of over-application
  • The applicator is also too thick to work well for thin eyelashes

Where to buy it: Amazon, ULTA

Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Mascara

Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Mascara

For lashes so big, it's almost criminal. This Waterproof mascara has a supersized formula with 3x the collagen and 3x the keratin.

Check Current Price
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

If you find the Too Faced BTS mascara’s formula too thick, then you should turn towards the Rimmel Scandaleyes mascara. A few people find Better than Sex to be a little clumpy and complain that it dries out too quickly. This makes the Rimmel mascara different from BTS. Some reviewers have also reported this mascara as ‘too thin.’   

The collagen and keratin-infused formula of this mascara is great for promoting smooth and voluminous eyelashes without drying them out. It also offers both waterproof and washable formulas. At such an economical price, you should try this drugstore duper and check it out for yourself.

Pros:

  • Adds definition, thickness and length to your lashes
  • Extremely cheap
  • Good Quality
  • Thin formula 

Cons:

  • Not everyone is a fan of the thin formula so it might be too watery for some people

Where to buy it: Amazon

CoverGirl Exhibitionist Very Black Mascara

CoverGirl Exhibitionist Very Black Mascara

This volumizing mascara formula glides smoothly onto lashes. 

Check Current Price
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

If you’re looking to save a few bucks while getting a ravishing mascara, then you should turn to the CoverGirl’s Exhibitionist Very Black Mascara. As CoverGirl is a vegan and cruelty-free brand, this product is for ethically conscious makeup enthusiasts who want budget-friendly products. CoverGirl’s mascara lengthens and separates your lashes. Its formula also claims not to smudge or flake.

Pros:

  • Lengthens lashes
  • Makes them look thicker, giving a fuller look
  • Curls lashes
  • The brush is super-easy to use
  • Smudge-proof
  • Darkens lashes without looking harsh
  • Safe too wear with contact lenses
  • Comes in two colors – black and brown

Cons:

  • Makes lashes clumpy
  • The brush is too big
  • The shape of the brush gathers too much product and can’t reach the corner of the eyes
  • The excess product causes a lot of smudging and clumping

Where to buy it: Amazon, ULTA

NYX Worth The Hype Mascara

NYX Worth The Hype Mascara

This mascara is effortless to apply and comfortable to wear. Definitely "Worth The Hype".

Check Current Price
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

NYX Professional Makeup offers some of the most budget-friendly makeup products out there. Their Hype Mascara is not only easy to apply, but it also has a special formula for bold and fuller eyelashes.

With a name like Worth The Hype, we’re sure you’re wondering if this mascara is worth the hype; well, it is. The wand of this mascara is a regular brush, which is neither too big nor too small. The brush tapers well, allowing it to reach the nooks and crannies of your eyes.

The NYX mascara is easy to apply to the upper lashes, but not so much on the lower ones. The formula dries at an average pace after application, which can be a bit of a turnoff. This mascara gets a little dry and brittle once it dries up completely. This means it can crumble when touched. It’s super-easy to remove and is not water-proof.

Pros:

  • Intensely black
  • Heavy volume
  • Offers lashes a great length
  • Separates lashes instead of making them clumpy
  • Easy to apply on the top lashes

Cons:

  • Difficult to apply on the bottom lashes
  • Gets brittle after drying
  • Can start running if it gets wet

Where to buy it: Amazon, ULTA

Final Thoughts

The Too Faced Better than Sex mascara is a bit expensive for those who use mascara daily. Despite its great performance and voluminous look that it gives to your eyelashes, many people are searching for cheaper dupes.

From all the drugstore dupes that we have discussed, the best one is the L’Oréal Paris’ Lash Paradise. It promises similar results as the BTS mascara but at a reasonable price.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Better than Sex mascara run?

No, the BTS mascara is waterproof and doesn’t run.

Is Too Faced cruelty-free?

Too Faced has confirmed to the fact that they’re completely cruelty-free. They don’t test their ingredients or their finished makeup products on animals. Also, they have made sure that none of their suppliers or any of the third parties they’re involved with test on animals either. They also don’t sell their products in places where animal testing is essential by law.

That being said, Too Faced is definitely cruelty-free, even though it is owned by Estée Lauder, a makeup and skincare company that tests on animals.

Get notified When We Post new articles and deals

We value your privacy and will only send you our best stuff. Promise.