MAC Chestnut Lip Pencil Dupes

6 Best MAC Chestnut Lip Pencil Dupes
*Essie Button is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Whether you’re just starting out doing makeup or you’re a seasoned professional, you’ve definitely heard of MAC Cosmetics. MAC Cosmetics is arguably one of the most popular makeup brands ever, and it seems like it is used by everyone and their mother. One of the products MAC is known for is their lip products.

MAC Lip Pencil Chestnut

This lip pencil has a smooth, creamy texture that is perfect for outlining lips or coloring them.

Check Current Price Read Our Review
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

The MAC Cosmetics Lip Pencil in the shade Chestnut is one of MAC’s bestsellers. Chestnut is an intense brown shade that looks great on many different skin tones. The formula is creamy, pigmented, and long-lasting. However, this product is not a budget-friendly option. Here are the best dupes for the MAC Lip Pencils, our favorite being the NYX Slim Lip Pencil in Espresso.

MAC Chestnut Lip Pencils Dupes

The MAC Lip Pencil in the shade Chestnut is a popular choice among makeup consumers. MAC’s Lip Pencils work as either an all-over lip color or just a lip liner. They have creamy formulas that are comfortable to wear, and they last all day long without budging. In one swipe, you have an excellent color payoff. However, the one thing they have going against them is the price. Let’s dive into the best dupes for the MAC Lip Pencil in the shade Chestnut.

NYX Slim Lip Pencil in Espresso

NYX Slim Lip Pencil In Espresso

This lip pencil has a creamy and hydrating formula, which smoothly glides onto your lips and blends in a breeze.

Check Current Price Read Our Review
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

NYX is one of the most popular makeup brands at the drugstore. And their Slim Lip Pencil in Espresso is almost an exact dupe for the MAC one.

The shade Espresso is a perfect shade match to Chestnut – one of the reasons it is our top dupe. Hence the name, this lip pencil is very slim. This means you can get a precise line in difficult areas such as the outer corners of the lip and the cupid’s bow. The velvety formula is lightweight and comfortable on the lips. This product is very long-lasting, so you won’t need to retouch it throughout the day. Also, NYX is cruelty-free!

One of the only things users dislike about this product is the unpleasant scent.

Pros:

  • Slim pencil makes it easy to make precise lines
  • Perfect shade match to MAC’s Chestnut
  • Feels lightweight and comfortable
  • long-lasting
  • Cruelty-free
  • Affordable

Cons:

  • Unpleasant scent

Where to buy it: Amazon

L.A. Girl Perfect Precision Lip Liner in Chocolate

Although L.A. Girl is not known as one of the more high-quality makeup brands at the drugstore, they do have some great products. One of them is the Precision Lip Liners.

The Perfect Precision Lip Liner in Chocolate is a very close shade match to MAC’s Chestnut. The formula is highly pigmented, so you get an amazing color payoff in a single swipe. It is very long-lasting, so you won’t have to reapply it throughout the day. Also, the formula feels very creamy and velvety making it comfortable to wear on the lips. L.A. Girl is a cruelty-free brand.

Something people dislike about this product is the application. Often times, it can apply in an uneven layer which feels and looks off on the lips. Also, it smears and transfers easily.

Pros:

  • Close shade match to Chestnut
  • Highly pigmented
  • Feels comfortable on the lips
  • Long-lasting
  • Cruelty-free
  • Inexpensive

Cons:

  • Can apply in an uneven layer
  • Not transfer-proof

Where to buy it: Ulta

Maybelline Color Sensational Shaping Lip Liner in Rich Chocolate

Maybelline Color Sensational Shaping Lip Liner In Rich Chocolate

Easily define your lip shape with this creamy lip liner.

Check Current Price Read Our Review
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

Maybelline is one of the oldest and best makeup brands at the drugstore. For decades, Maybelline has been making great quality makeup for an affordable cost. Their Sensational Shaping Lip Liners are a fan favorite.

This lip liner in the shade Rich Chocolate is a close shade match to MAC’s Chestnut. This pencil is actually retractable, so it is easy to use since you don’t have to manually sharpen it. The formula is super creamy and comfortable on the lips. It is highly pigmented, so you get a great color payoff in a single swipe. Also, there is no feathering or bleeding with this product.

One of the things that turns people off about this product is the unpleasant scent. Also, you should know that Maybelline is not yet a cruelty-free makeup brand.

Pros:

  • Close shade match to MAC’s Chestnut
  • Retractable pencil
  • Easy to use
  • Highly pigmented
  • No feathering or bleeding
  • Budget-friendly

Cons:

  • Unpleasant scent
  • Not cruelty-free

Where to buy it: Amazon

Makeup Revolution Satin Kiss Lipliner in TGIF

Makeup Revolution is slowly but surely making their way up in the makeup community. The Satin Kiss Lipliners is one of their bestsellers and is a great dupe for the MAC liners.

The shade TGIF is a bit more red-toned than Chestnut, but they are pretty similar. This lip pencil is highly pigmented, so you don’t need to use a lot to get a good color payoff. Since you only need to use one or two swipes, it feels lightweight and comfortable on the lips. It is super long-lasting and stays in place all day long. There is no bleeding or transferring when using this product. Also, Makeup Revolution is a cruelty-free makeup brand.

Something to note about this product is its unpleasant scent. Also, it is not easy to sharpen.

Pros:

  • Highly pigmented
  • Feels lightweight and comfortable on the lips
  • Long-lasting
  • No bleeding or transferring
  • Cruelty-free
  • Affordable

Cons:

  • Unpleasant scent
  • Not easily to sharpen

Where to buy it: Ulta

KKW Beauty Nude Lip Liner in Nude 3

Kim Kardashian’s cosmetics line, KKW Beauty, is a new brand that has gained tons of popularity. The Nude Lip Liners are some of the brand’s bestsellers. The shade Nude 3 is a great dupe for MAC’s lip pencil in Chestnut.

This lip liner has a creamy formula that feels lightweight on the lips. It doesn’t feel drying at all and it isn’t flaky. It is incredibly long-lasting, so you won’t need to reapply it throughout the day. The tip of this liner provides an even application that smoothly glides onto the lips. Also, it is transfer-proof. KKW Beauty is a cruelty-free makeup brand.

Something users dislike about this product is that it doesn’t sharpen easily. In fact, when people have attempted to sharpen this pencil, it has even broken on them. Also, the packaging is flimsy and the cap doesn’t stay on securely. This does not make it optimal for traveling.

Pros:

  • Not drying or flaky
  • Long-lasting
  • Glides smoothly onto the lips
  • Transfer-proof
  • Cruelty-free
  • Affordable

Cons:

  • Does not sharpen easily
  • Not optimal for traveling

Where to buy it: Ulta

Essence Stay 8H Waterproof Lipliner in I Am Shooketh!

Essence has some of the best and, in my opinion, most underrated makeup at the drugstore. The Stay 8H Waterproof Lipliner is a bestseller of theirs.

This lip liner is a great choice for beginners. It is affordable, accessible, and very easy to use. Hence the name, this liner supposedly lasts 8 hours. Since it is so long-lasting, it is great for people with busy lives that don’t have time to reapply their lipstick all the time. It stays in place all day and doesn’t transfer. Also, it is highly pigmented, so you get a great color payoff in a single swipe. Essence is 100% cruelty-free and vegan.

Reviewers say that the retractable packaging makes it difficult to get more product out. This is because it doesn’t twist up and down very easily. Also, it is not waterproof.

Pros:

  • Great for beginners
  • Lasts 8 hours
  • Does not transfer
  • Highly pigmented
  • Cruelty-free and vegan
  • Inexpensive

Cons:

  • Inconvenient packaging
  • Not waterproof

Where to buy it: Ulta

Final Thoughts

The MAC Lip Pencil in Chestnut is a very popular product. But, if you are on a budget, it may not be the right option for you. That’s why we’ve rounded up the best dupes that give the same results for a fraction of the cost. Our favorite is the NYX Slim Lip Pencil in Espresso.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a lip liner do?

Lip liners help to give shape and definition to your lips. They especially look great underneath another lip color or gloss. Another use for lip liner is to prevent your main lip color from bleeding or feathering. Also, lip liner can be used to correct uneven lip shapes or make the lips appear fuller.

Is a lip liner necessary?

No, a lip liner is not necessary. But, it can add extra definition to your lips, make your lipstick last longer, and make it look better. It can be a great tool if you have thin lips.

How do you apply lip liner?

You should apply lip liner after a lip balm and before the main lip product. You want to outline the edges of your lips, making sure not to underline or overline too much. If you do overline, make sure it isn’t overly dramatic, or else it will look fake. You can either fill in the entire lips with the liner or just define the edges.

Get notified When We Post new articles and deals

We value your privacy and will only send you our best stuff. Promise.