MAC Velvet Teddy Matte Lipstick Review + The Best Dupes!

MAC Velvet Teddy review
*Essie Button is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

A nude lip is an essential go-to product for anyone’s makeup routine – whether you’re a makeup beginner or beauty guru! But, let’s face it… finding the perfect nude lip color can be surprisingly difficult. That is why the MAC Matte Lipstick in the shade “Velvet Teddy” has gained so much exposure and popularity among makeup lovers.

MAC Velvet Teddy Matte Lipstick is the perfect neutral lip shade for everyday wear. Its velvety, smooth texture prevents the lips from drying out, allowing for maximum comfort throughout the day. As far as dupes go, our favorite would have to be the ColourPop Lippie Pencil in the shade “Oh Snap.”

MAC Velvet Teddy Matte Lipstick Review

MAC Velvet Teddy
A Creme-Based Lipstick that Imparts Bright Colour with a Soft and Supple Shine.
Check Current Price
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

The MAC Velvet Teddy Matte Lipstick is a well-rounded lipstick that has so many benefits. This lipstick leaves a matte finish, but it isn’t drying like most other matte lipsticks (which is one of my personal makeup pet peeves).

One of the great things about this lipstick is how versatile it is! It can be used to balance out a full face of makeup or as the final touch to a natural “no-makeup” makeup look. As far as the color goes, this lipstick is a deep beige tone that can give off pink hues in some lighting. Remember: the color might appear slightly different depending on your skin tone.

If you are looking to amp up your makeup look a little bit more, this lipstick also works well with the MAC Lipglass in the shade “spite” on top of it! Their matching shades and formulas complement each other perfectly, and it’ll intensify your overall look.

I’d say one of the downfalls of this product is that you have to swipe it a couple of times on your lips to get a good color payoff. This means that you would also have to reapply it throughout the day to keep the pigment there. But, other than that, this is a great product that can make a great addition to your makeup collection!

If you are looking for a second review/perspective of the MAC Velvet Teddy Matte Lipstick, click here.

MAC Velvet Teddy Matte Lipstick Dupes

Even though the MAC Velvet Teddy Matte Lipstick is an exceptional product, it isn’t the most budget-friendly option. If you are on the search for a great alternative to this lip product, look no further. Here are some of the best dupes for the MAC Velvet Teddy Matte Lipstick.

Sephora Cream Lip Stain In Classic Beige

Sephora Cream Lip Stain In Classic Beige
A silky, long-lasting lip stain that keeps lips covered with bold color from AM to PM—no need to reapply or touch up throughout the day.
Check Current Price
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

Sephora’s Cream Lip Stain in the shade “Classic Beige (02)” is pretty much identical to Velvet Teddy. It is a warm-toned light brown shade with pink undertones, and it has the same matte finish. The pigmentation of this product is excellent. With only a single layer of lipstick, the lips are almost completely pigmented. So, this is a very comfortable, lightweight product to wear throughout the day.

Once you apply this lipstick, it can take a bit to dry, so it’ll feel slightly tacky on the lips (but not uncomfortable). Also, since it is a lip stain, it lasts much longer than a typical lipstick – great for everyday wear!

Pros:

  • It is long-lasting throughout the day
  • Pigment is very opaque
  • Almost the exact shade as Velvet Teddy

Cons:

  • Can feel tacky on the lips
  • It lasts so long that it can even be difficult to remove from the lips

Where to buy it: Sephora

ColourPop Lippie Pencil In Oh Snap

ColourPop Lippie Stix In Oh Snap
Get one swipe pigmentation in a full-coverage, matte finish in a super comfortable formula loaded with skin-loving ingredients like shea butter and Vitamin E.
Check Current Price
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

The Lippie Pencils by Colour Pop have a thick tip that can work as either a lip pencil or a traditional lipstick. This shade is almost identical to Velvet Teddy except it has a tinge of very light brown. It looks beautiful by itself as a lipstick, but it can also be a base for another shade to prevent feathering.

This is the most budget-friendly option on this list, but don’t get that confused with it being low quality. Colourpop cosmetics has some of my favorite lip products, as they are very opaque on the lips. Also, they are comfortable to wear throughout the day.

Pros:

  • Long-lasting
  • The color payoff is highly pigmented
  • Budget-friendly

Cons:

  • Can be difficult to sharpen
  • Color is browner and lighter than Velvet Teddy

Where to buy it: Amazon

Milani Color Statement Lipstick in Matte Naked 

Milani Color Statement Lipstick in Matte Naked
Matte to the max! Milani's Color Statement Matte Lipsticks give you statement-making bold color and lip looks that last.
Check Current Price
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

Milani’s lipstick in Matte Naked is a great, everyday nude and while it’s a hint more cool toned then Velvet Teddy, they appear very similar on the lips. Milani’s hydrating formula along with its luxurious, gold packaging allows you to experience a high quality product at an affordable price tag.

Pros:

  • Cruelty Free.
  • Reviewers rave about the color-payoff and non-drying formula.
  • The packaging gives the product a more luxurious feel.

Cons:

  • This lipstick has a light, vanilla cake scent that some may dislike.
  • This is a more hydrating formula and not the most long-wearing so be prepared to reapply throughout the day.

Where to buy it: Amazon

Maybelline Color Sensational The Creams In Nude Lust

Maybelline Color Sensational The Creams In Nude Lust
Sensational color takes on a new feeling with The Creams lipstick, delivering pure color pigments and infused with Shea Butter.
Check Current Price
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

Maybelline Color Sensational The Creams in the shade “Nude Lust” is almost the exact shade as Velvet Teddy – a warm beige with pink undertones. But, it has a luminous finish instead of being completely matte. It is only lightly pigmented, so you can build it up to create a bold look. But, you can also apply a single layer to let your natural lip shade shine through.

Since this product has a luminous finish, it is more moisturizing on the lips than a matte lipstick. So, it’s a perfect option for someone who is prone to dry lips. It is very easy to apply and a great product for makeup beginners!

Pros:

  • Very moisturizing
  • Similar shade to Velvet Teddy
  • Easy to apply and great for beginners

Cons:

  • Instead of a matte finish, it has a luminous finish
  • Not as pigmented as other products

Where to buy it: Amazon

NYX Matte Lipstick In Euro Trash

NYX Euro Trash Matte Lipstick
A shockingly smooth matte lipstick that glides right on and stays in place with a silky matte finish.
Check Current Price
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

The NYX Matte Lipstick in the shade Euro Trash is a warm-toned beige color. It has more mauve tones compared to MAC’s Velvet Teddy. It still has the same matte finish, but this product cream formula allows it to be more moisturizing – and it’s not sticky or tacky at all!

The product is very pigmented with only a single layer, so it feels very lightweight for everyday wear. Also, it’s perfect for budget-friendly shoppers!

Pros:

  • Despite being matte, it is very moisturizing
  • Not sticky or tacky
  • Budget-friendly

Cons:

  • More mauve than Velvet Teddy
  • It never gets completely dried down

Where to buy it: Amazon

Final Thoughts

MAC Velvet Teddy Matte Lipstick is a matte lipstick that is the perfect shade for a variety of different skin tones. Despite being a matte lip product, it isn’t drying on the lips, so it is perfect for everyday wear!

But, the product isn’t very budget-friendly. After looking at the best dupes for this product, our favorite is the Colour Pop Lippie Pencil in the shade “Oh Snap”. It is comfortable to wear, very similar in color and finish to Velvet Teddy, and budget-friendly! But, you really can’t go wrong with any of the products on our list.

Frequently Asked Questions

What products look best with a nude lip?

The great thing about a nude lip is that it’s so versatile! You can wear it with a smokey eye to balance out the look or you could use it to complement an all-natural, effortless look. For this reason, having a go-to nude lipstick in your makeup collection is essential.

Where is the best place to buy these dupes?

Well, there are benefits to buying makeup products both online and in-store. The great thing about buying in-store is that you can swatch it in person and see if you like it. But, when you shop online, you get the read customer reviews and you can search for deals easier.

How do I prevent matte lipsticks from drying out my lips?

One of the greatest downfalls of matte lipsticks, and what makes a good one hard to find, is that they can be quite drying on the lips! This makes it very uncomfortable to wear throughout the day. Like MAC’s matte lipstick, a cream formula can help a ton. Also, always make sure to moisturize your lips with a hydrating lip balm before applying any mattifying product!