Tatcha Silk Canvas Primer is like having an Instagram filter in a compact! It’s GREAT for creating a flawless base to apply your makeup. Beauty gurus adore this product because it’s just what you need to create that flawless, snatched, full glam look. Tatcha is a luxury brand with luxury prices and they’re products are usually pretty hype, which means we need a Tatcha Silk Canvas Primer Dupe. Silk Canvas is a good product but how much is too much to pay for something you apply your makeup over?
e.l.f.’s Poreless Putty Primer is the drugstore’s answer to Tatcha’s miracle-working, putty primer. It’s a putty primer that targets pores, texture and blurs the skin to look flawless. We love e.l.f. because it’s affordable and when paired side-by-side, it’s hard to spot the difference between these two primers. e.l.f.’s primer is a great dupe and if you’re wanting to try out a putty primer, definitely save some money and go for the e.l.f. one first.
Tatcha The Silk Canvas Review
Tatcha uses high quality ingredients so Silk Canvas is free of parabens, phthalates and it’s non-comedogenic.
Tatcha Silk Canvas Primer is a velvet primer that helps to blur pores and texture along with helping your makeup last longer. This primer is geared towards those looking to conceal texture and pores or those that love a flawless look! It’s not too heavy on the skin nor is it sticky, think of a putty, velvety texture.
Tatcha uses high quality ingredients so Silk Canvas is free of parabens, phthalates and it’s non-comedogenic. This product is a makeup/skincare hybrid so it’ll keep makeup out of pores and prevent future breakouts. This helps to make the price a little more justifiable but it’s still up there and definitely a splurge! The only con is Silk Canvas is highly fragranced, think herbal and florals so if you’re sensitive to fragrance in any way beware of that.
Where to buy it: Amazon
Tatcha Silk Canvas Primer Dupes
Tatcha Silk Canvas is easily one of the most popular primers at the moment. Luckily, e.l.f. has released a line of putty primers that are a great alternative to Tatcha with a much cheaper price tag. The only con with Tatcha Silk Canvas Primer dupes is you won’t be getting all the skincare benefits that you would with the original product. If you’re looking for skincare benefits, you’re better off spending your money on a quality serum to apply before your primer and makeup.
e.l.f. Poreless Putty Primer
The velvety texture of Poreless Putter Primer glides effortlessly over your skin, smoothing over imperfections.
This e.l.f. primer took the beauty community by storm when it launched dupes just a little bit after Tatcha Silk Canvas debuted! e.l.f.’s version has the same putty consistency as Tatcha, blurs pores and texture and leaves the same flawless finish. The best part is that e.l.f. is much more affordable than Tatcha! Having tried both, the thing I like about e.l.f. is that it’s fragrance free while Tatcha is highly scented and smells like flowers and essential oils.
Pros:
- Affordable. You can buy about 6 e.l.f. primers for one Tatcha Primer.
- Formula performs like Tatcha Silk Canvas!
- Fragranced free formula is gentler on skin and has less room for irritation.
- Cruelty-free and vegan.
- Makes your makeup last longer.
- Contains squalane to hydrate and grip onto the skin.
Cons:
- The packaging is not as nice as Tatcha.
- Does not come with a little metal disk to scoop out product.
Where to buy it: Amazon
Makeup Revolution Conceal & Fix Pore Perfecting Primer
Makeup Revolution Conceal & Fix helps to extend the wear time on your makeup and it’s super affordable.
This Makeup Revolution primer is a putty texture made to smooth pores and texture pre-makeup application. It’ll help to extend the wear time on your makeup and it’s super affordable. Like e.l.f., this affordable alternative is a great Tatcha Silk Canvas Primer dupe and is a great way to try the product for less.
Pros:
- Creates the illusion of a smooth, poreless complexion.
- Affordable.
- Fragrance free — good for sensitive skin types.
- Comes with a spatula to scoop out product.
Cons:
- Some reviewers said they prefer the e.l.f. putty primer to this due to smell.
- Some reviewers said the product crumbles.
Where to buy it: Beauty Bay
L’Oreal Paris Magic Perfecting Base Face Primer
This lightweight primer glides onto your skin and minimizes the look of pores and fine lines.
L’Oreal Paris’ Magic Face Primer is matte and gives a flawless finish for perfect makeup application. The good thing about this primer is it’s non-comedogenic so if you’re worried about a putty primer clogging your pores, this shouldn’t. This primer can be used all over, under the eyes or to spot correct an area!
Pros:
- Non-comedogenic.
- Flawless, matte finish that blurs pores.
- Works well for mature skin.
Cons:
- Not cruelty-free.
- Some may find this product a bit thick.
Where to buy it: Amazon
E.L.F Matte Putty Primer
If you have oily skin, e.l.f. Matte Putty Primer is a great option and it’s very long-lasting.
This e.l.f.’s Matte Putty Primer is just like their original Poreless Putty Primer but geared for oily skin or for days when you really want your makeup to last. Reviewers call this the pumped-up, more intense version of the original Poreless Putty primer! If you have oily skin, this is a great option and it’s very long-lasting. If you have dry skin, go for the original Poreless Putty version!
Pros:
- Stronger and longer lasting than the original Poreless Putty Primer.
- Affordable.
- Vegan and cruelty-free.
- Good option for oily skin types.
- Offers a long-wearing matte finish.
Cons:
- Not suitable for dry skin.
- Does not contain skincare benefits like Tatcha.
- Does not come with a disk or spatula to scoop out product.
Where to buy it: Amazon
Revolution Pro Blur Stick Face Primer
Revolution Pro Blur Stick comes in a stick format and it’s really easy to just apply all over your face.
Unlike Tatcha Silk Canvas, this Revolution primer comes in a stick format and it’s really easy to just apply all over the face. This product will apply a bit thinner then Tatcha but it’s great for blurring pores, imperfection and creating a flawless base. If you like to keep your makeup light and hate that heavy feeling, this is a good option!
Pros:
- Stick formula makes for quick, easy application.
- Blur pores effortlessly.
- Lighter texture makes for comfortable wear.
- Affordable.
- Good for no-makeup days or light makeup.
Cons:
- Not a putty like Tatcha.
- Not as full coverage as Tatcha.
Where to buy it: Ulta
Winky Lux Whipped Cream Primer
Winky Lux Whipped Cream Primer feels weightless, extends the wear time of your makeup, and creates a flawless base.
This Winky Lux primer has a whipped cream texture aimed for blurring fine lines, pores and imperfections. It feels weightless, extends the wear time of your makeup and creates a flawless base. If you have dry skin, the cream texture would be a good option for you as it’s more hydrating than the other dupes listed. While it’s the most expensive dupe on this list it’s still less than half the price of Tatcha!
Pros:
- Paraben, phthalate and gluten-free. Also vegan and cruelty-free.
- Comes in luxurious packaging with a gold top.
- Whipped texture makes it lightweight and comfortable to wear.
- Great option for dry skin as it helps to hydrate!
Cons:
- Some reviewers said the formula is inconsistent when they went to restock.
- Some reviews said it pilled up under foundation.
- Not as affordable as the e.l.f. Putty Primer.
- Seems to be out of stock more often than other Tatcha Silk Canvas Primer dupes.
Where to buy it: Amazon
Final Thoughts
There’s no doubt that Tatcha Silk Canvas is a great primer if you’re looking for a flawless, airbrushed looking base. But you don’t have to shell out the luxury price tag to get that look. e.l.f.’s Poreless Putty Primer is an excellent dupe for a fraction of the price! I mean down to texture, the color and performance it’s like Tatcha Silk Canvas minus the floral, herbal scent.
I know some people swear by primers and some people don’t think they do much. e.l.f.’s Poreless Putty primer will smooth out pores and imperfections along with extending the wear time of your makeup. Exactly what you would want your primer to do! Overall, Tatcha and e.l.f.’s primers are very similar so you might as well save some money and go for the e.l.f. one if you’re looking for a good primer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does this primer cause flashback?
No, most of the time flashback with makeup is caused by either SPF or powder. SPF not so much anymore as the formulas advance! A loose powder is usually the culprit because of the ingredients silica and mica. They’re shiny and create the white powdery, unblended look on the face when met with flash photography.
Will this primer dry out my skin?
If you have dry skin you may feel dry so my recommendation is to use two primers. Use the putty primer in areas that need it most. Usually the t-zone, cheeks and forehead or wherever you have pores and texture that you want to eliminate. Then use a hydrating primer on all the areas you missed and that should help with dryness.
Do I need to wear a primer at all?
This is highly debatable because some swear by primers and some think they don’t do anything. I’ve been both of those people so I can say, if you think your primer isn’t doing anything then it’s not the right one. If you’re looking to minimize the appearance of pores and texture, your best chance is with a primer so you just need to find the right one.
I think the problem with primers is that most are just geared towards hydrating and that will serve like a basic moisturizer. If you’re looking to see a noticeable difference in your skin, go for one that will blur imperfections or mattify the skin. That’s when you’ll truly notice a difference in your makeup! When you find the right one, you’ll totally appreciate the importance of a good primer.